On 1 September 2025, the Holy See Press Office confirmed that Pope Leo XIV received Fr James Martin SJ in a private audience at the Apostolic Palace. The American Jesuit was in Rome accompanying a Jubilee pilgrimage organised by his LGBT ministry, Outreach. The encounter, which Fr Martin quickly made public on X, echoed the frequent papal audiences granted to him under Pope Francis.
“Dear friends: I was honoured and grateful to meet with the Holy Father @Pontifex this morning in an audience in the Apostolic Palace, and moved to hear the same message I heard from Pope Francis on LGBTQ Catholics, which is one of openness and welcome. I found Pope Leo to be serene, joyful, and encouraging. For me, it was a deeply consoling meeting. Please pray for the Holy Father!”¹
The Vatican offered no details beyond the announcement, but Martin’s testimony suggested continuity with Pope Francis’ “pastoral and progressive” tone. This raises pressing questions: does the new pontificate intend to continue the policy of privileging dialogue over doctrinal clarity, or is the audience simply a gesture of courtesy?
The Martin Phenomenon
Fr Martin has been a lightning rod of controversy in the Church since the publication of Building a Bridge in 2017.² In it, he urged a new “dialogue” with LGBT Catholics, emphasising listening, welcome, and inclusion. Admirers, especially among progressive bishops, saw him as a pioneer of pastoral accompaniment. Critics, however, argued that his rhetoric subtly undermines the perennial magisterium on chastity, marriage, and the moral law.³
This tension has only deepened through Outreach, his LGBT ministry. The group’s stated mission is “to support LGBTQ Catholics in their faith,” and Martin often insists that he fully upholds the Catechism.⁴ Yet, the events sponsored by Outreach regularly feature speakers and organisations which openly reject or campaign against Catholic doctrine on sexual ethics, marriage, and even the natural law.⁵ Thus, a profound contradiction emerges: while Martin professes loyalty to the Church’s teaching, the platforms and partnerships of his apostolate repeatedly advance positions at odds with that teaching.
“While Fr James Martin’s ministry mirrors secular LGBT activism and omits the call to chastity, the Titular Archbishop of Selsey insists in ‘Omnium hominum‘ that true pastoral charity must unite compassion with the discipline of holiness.”
Contradictions in Policy and Teaching
For example, the Catechism teaches that same-sex acts are “intrinsically disordered” and can “under no circumstances be approved,” while calling for respect and pastoral care for persons who experience such inclinations.⁶ By contrast, Outreach conferences routinely invite speakers who promote the blessing of same-sex unions, gender ideology, or the reinterpretation of Catholic anthropology.⁷ Martin himself, when pressed, avoids direct affirmation of the Church’s moral prohibitions, preferring to emphasise “dialogue” and “accompaniment.”
The point is clear: none of the groups with which Martin associates himself champion or even propose the Catholic call to chastity and celibacy. Instead, they consistently mirror and reflect the agendas of secular LGBT activism—promoting sexual expression, recognition of same-sex unions, and gender ideology—while remaining silent on the universal Christian summons to holiness. In this way, Martin’s ministry becomes indistinguishable in practice from secular advocacy, despite his assurances of doctrinal fidelity.
Synodal Politics and Papal Reception
During the Synod on Synodality in 2023, Martin sat with then-Cardinal Robert Prevost, now Prefect of the Dicastery for Bishops, whom he praised for a leadership style “similar to Pope Francis.”⁸ That association, and now his early audience with Pope Leo XIV, suggest that his influence will remain intact.
The papal reception of Martin is not merely personal—it is political. To grant a private audience to such a polarising figure is to send a signal: pastoral outreach, even when entangled with doctrinal ambiguity and secular activism, will be rewarded with papal attention.
The Perennial Teaching
Against this backdrop, the Church’s magisterium remains unambiguous. From Persona Humana (1975) to the Catechism of the Catholic Church (1992), and reaffirmed in documents such as Considerations Regarding Proposals to Give Legal Recognition to Unions Between Homosexual Persons (2003), the teaching is consistent: homosexual acts are contrary to natural law, same-sex unions cannot be blessed, and any pastoral approach must be grounded in the truth of the Gospel.⁹ A ministry that muddles this truth, even with sincere intentions, risks replacing accompaniment with accommodation, and pastoral charity with doctrinal dilution.
Conclusion: Continuity in Confusion
The meeting between Pope Leo XIV and Fr Martin cannot be dismissed as mere courtesy. It represents a conscious decision to extend papal favour to a ministry shaped not by Catholic ascetic and moral tradition, but by the language and priorities of secular activism. It signals that under Leo XIV, as under Francis, “welcome” will often eclipse clarity, and “dialogue” will be allowed to substitute for doctrine.
For Catholics who seek firm leadership in an age of moral confusion, this is not a hopeful sign. The faithful may well interpret the audience as confirmation that the new pontificate is a continuation, not a correction, of the modernist trajectory that privileges worldly recognition over apostolic fidelity.
True pastoral care must unite compassion with truth, welcome with conversion, and accompaniment with the call to holiness. Without this balance, papal gestures risk emboldening those who reject the perennial teaching of the Church and discouraging those who strive to live by it. In this light, the faithful must pray more fervently than ever: that Pope Leo XIV will have the courage not only to console, but to confirm his brethren in the truth.
Footnotes
¹ James Martin SJ, X (1 September 2025).
² James Martin SJ, Building a Bridge (New York: HarperOne, 2017).
³ Robert Cardinal Sarah, The Day is Now Far Spent (San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 2019), pp. 135–138.
⁴ Outreach, Mission Statement, accessed 2025.
⁵ Outreach Conference 2022–2024 programs, featuring speakers advocating same-sex blessings and gender ideology.
⁶ Catechism of the Catholic Church, nn. 2357–2359.
⁷ See, for example, Outreach 2023, keynote addresses calling for doctrinal revision on marriage.
⁸ America Magazine, “At the Synod with Cardinal Prevost” (2023).
⁹ Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Persona Humana (1975); CDF, Considerations Regarding Proposals to Give Legal Recognition to Unions Between Homosexual Persons (2003).
COMMENT: Two Divergent Approaches
Fr James Martin’s LGBT ministry, Outreach, has become synonymous with dialogue and inclusion. Yet its conferences and partnerships reflect secular activist agendas rather than the Church’s perennial call to chastity. None of the groups with which he collaborates uphold celibacy or sexual self-discipline; instead, they promote recognition of same-sex unions, gender ideology, and the affirmation of sexual identities divorced from Catholic morality.
By contrast, the Titular Archbishop of Selsey in his 2023 epistle Omnium hominum framed chastity as essential for all Christians, regardless of state in life. He taught that chastity is both a discipline and a grace, enabling love of God and neighbour, and that true compassion cannot be severed from truth. While Martin risks confusing accompaniment with accommodation, the Archbishop insists that genuine pastoral charity must guide souls towards holiness, never away from it.
Leave a Reply