NUNTIATORIA

Unequal Measures: Downplaying the Many, Exaggerating the Few

The figures from London’s recent mass gatherings tell a story very different from the headlines. At this year’s Notting Hill Carnival, police reported 528 arrests over the Bank Holiday weekend, with crowd sizes estimated between one and two million people.¹²³ That amounts to roughly 26–53 arrests per 100,000 attendees.

At the Palestine Action protest in Parliament Square on 6 September, about 1,500 people assembled. Metropolitan Police confirmed 890 arrests, of which 857 were under terrorism legislation (TACT) and 33 for other offences.⁴⁵⁶ This means that more than half the crowd—around 59% of those present—were taken into custody.

By contrast, the Unite the Kingdom march of 13 September filled Whitehall and beyond. Striking drone footage suggested crowds far larger than the “official” estimates of 110,000, yet police and media insisted on that figure. The Met confirmed 24 arrests on the day, with the majority linked to the main protest, and 26 officers injured.⁷⁸ Even at the lower official count, this equates to about 22 arrests per 100,000 participants—a remarkably small ratio when set beside the other gatherings.

The disparity is striking. In raw numbers, the Carnival and Palestine Action protests each produced far more arrests. In proportional terms, the Palestine Action rally was an unprecedented outlier, with a majority of attendees detained. Even Carnival, long criticised for disorder, produced a higher arrest rate per capita than Unite the Kingdom.

And yet, in the court of public perception, the UTK march has faced the sharpest censure. Politicians and churchmen alike rushed to denounce it as “divisive” and “dangerous,” while far more disruptive or violent assemblies were treated with comparative indulgence. The selective outrage reveals that what determines the narrative is not the scale of disorder but the sympathies of the establishment.

The downplaying of the crowd size at Unite the Kingdom is part of the same pattern. Where fashionable causes are often granted inflated attendance estimates, here the official figure was kept deliberately low, despite the mass of humanity visibly present on Whitehall. Such manipulation of perception is as telling as the disproportionate rhetoric about “public order.”

Measured against the yardstick of civic responsibility, the Unite the Kingdom rally was one of the most disciplined mass demonstrations in London in recent years. Twenty-four arrests among more than a hundred thousand participants is no cause for triumphalism—but it does put into question the consistency and integrity of those who shape the narrative.

Truth, Justice, and the Christian Measure

For Christians, these contrasts underline the duty to discern rightly. Scripture reminds us that “righteousness exalteth a nation: but sin is a reproach to any people” (Prov. 14:34). Public judgments, whether in politics or media, must rest on fact rather than perception, sympathy, or prejudice. As Our Lord taught, “Judge not according to the appearance, but judge righteous judgment” (John 7:24).

To apply one standard harshly to a gathering and another leniently to a different cause is to risk the partiality condemned by St James: “If you have respect to persons, ye commit sin, and are convinced of the law as transgressors” (James 2:9). Justice requires consistency; it requires fidelity to truth, even when truth unsettles prevailing narratives.

If peaceful assemblies are diminished and vilified, while more disorderly events are overlooked or excused, society loses its anchor in objective reality. The Church, for her part, must avoid echoing such distortions. She must instead call all men and women back to the eternal measure: “The Lord is a God of truth and without iniquity; just and right is he” (Deut. 32:4).

Footnotes
¹ Metropolitan Police, “Carnival weekend policing update,” 27 Aug. 2025 (528 arrests).
² Sky News, “More than a million expected at Notting Hill Carnival,” 25 Aug. 2025.
³ The Guardian, “Two million expected to attend Notting Hill Carnival,” 24 Aug. 2025.
⁴ Metropolitan Police, “Update on demonstration in support of Palestine Action,” 7 Sept. 2025 (890 total; 857 TACT; 33 other offences).
⁵ Evening Standard, live reporting confirming ~1,500 attendees and Met total arrests.
⁶ Al Jazeera, “London police arrest 890 at Palestine protest,” 7 Sept. 2025.
⁷ Reuters, “Over 100,000 anti-immigration protesters march in London,” 13 Sept. 2025.
⁸ Metropolitan Police, “Public order update: Unite the Kingdom protest,” 14 Sept. 2025 (24 arrests; 26 officers injured).