A Christmas organised around the satisfaction of children can leave them remarkably unprepared to give anything in return. The approach of Advent offers Catholic families an opportunity to recover the meaning of Christmas as the celebration of a divine gift and a school of gratitude, duty and charity.
The annual arrival of the Christmas advertisements now performs a function once reserved for the first decorations in the high street. It announces that the season has begun, sets the emotional register and supplies the story through which retailers hope families will understand their spending. John Lewis has become particularly accomplished in this art. Its 2026 production, Gloria and Pickles, stars Dame Kristin Scott Thomas as a grandmother struggling to decide what to give her grandchildren. A toy dog, rescued from the attic, sets her upon a journey towards recovering the pleasure of giving and the warmth of family life. The campaign’s declared message is that people should not give up on giving.1
The message is perfectly intelligible, and one need not regard a department store advertisement as a treatise on the Incarnation to recognise its merits. The grandmother’s original difficulty is familiar to many families. Children have so many possessions, and receive so many opportunities to choose for themselves, that even their grandparents may struggle to discover what would genuinely delight them. The temptation is to give money and avoid the anxiety of disappointing anyone. The advertisement’s solution is affectionate and theatrical, as advertisements generally are, but its underlying question is rather serious: what happens when gift-giving becomes an exercise in satisfying expectations which the recipient scarcely knows how to articulate?
A comparison with John Lewis’s celebrated 2011 advertisement, The Long Wait, is instructive. That story appears to concern a little boy impatient for Christmas morning. Only at the end does the viewer discover that he has been waiting for the opportunity to give his parents a present. The narrative succeeds because it reverses the assumption that a child must necessarily regard the feast as the moment when adults fulfil his desires. The child is eager to give, and in his eagerness reveals that he has already begun to understand love as something requiring initiative from himself.2
Neither advertisement can be treated as a reliable measurement of British family life, still less as proof of some neatly dated moral decline. Each is a commercial fiction crafted to sell goods through sentiment. Yet the persistence of Christmas advertising built upon anxiety over the perfect gift suggests that retailers recognise a familiar domestic predicament. Adults are encouraged to measure their success by the satisfaction of the young, while children are rarely asked to consider the labour, sacrifice and affection represented by what they receive.
This is the question which deserves more attention in the contemporary discussion of Christmas. Parents may labour for weeks to create what is called a magical experience. The decorations must be impressive, the food plentiful, the presents correctly chosen and the programme free from disappointment. The intention is often generous. The danger arises when the family unconsciously learns that the centre of Christmas is the child’s emotional satisfaction, and that the adults exist principally to provide it.
Christian parents have a more demanding responsibility. They are to love their children, provide for them according to their means and make legitimate occasions of joy memorable. They must also form the character by which children learn to receive generosity without assuming an entitlement to it. Gratitude is not a decorative courtesy attached to good manners. It is the recognition that something has been received from another, often at a cost which the recipient cannot fully comprehend. A child who has never been taught that recognition is deprived of a necessary part of moral education.
That education requires more than insisting upon an appropriately enthusiastic thank-you after the wrapping paper has been torn away. Children must be allowed to give, to prepare, to save, to remember others and sometimes to make sacrifices for someone else’s happiness. A small present chosen for a parent, a handmade card for a grandparent, a contribution towards a charitable collection or a visit to someone alone can teach the relationship between love and action more effectively than an elaborate lecture about selfishness.
The obligation falls upon adults as well. A family can easily celebrate generosity towards itself while neglecting an elderly relation, a lonely neighbour or someone who has recently suffered bereavement. The crowded calendar becomes the excuse by which those in greatest need of company are postponed until January, when the decorations have been put away and the opportunity for a shared feast has passed. Hospitality is demanding precisely because it requires making room for another person rather than simply expanding the arrangements for one’s own comfort.
The Catholic understanding of Christmas supplies an objective reason for these obligations. The feast commemorates the Nativity of Our Lord Jesus Christ, the eternal Son of God Who assumed human nature for our salvation. Its centre is an act of divine generosity which no human present can imitate adequately. The Word made flesh did not come into the world in order to confirm our existing preferences. The mystery of Bethlehem reveals both the charity of God and the humility through which men must learn to receive Him.
Children cannot be expected to grasp every theological distinction involved in the Incarnation, but they are capable of understanding far more than the commercial presentation of Christmas often assumes. They can learn that Our Lord was born in poverty, that the shepherds came to adore Him, that the Magi brought gifts in homage, and that the Holy Family lived by fidelity and obedience. Those narratives connect naturally with the conduct expected of a Catholic household. Christmas generosity begins to make sense when the recipient is taught why generosity is owed.
The Church’s calendar is of practical assistance. In the Roman Rite Advent begins this year on 29 November. Its character of preparation, watchfulness and penitence creates a necessary distinction between anticipation and fulfilment. The household which turns all of November and December into a prolonged Christmas celebration can unintentionally make the feast itself feel like the exhaustion of a season already spent. Children benefit from learning that there are appropriate times to prepare, to refrain, to rejoice and to give thanks.
Within that rhythm there is ample room for the customs which have long made Catholic homes places of religious formation. The Advent wreath, the family crib, the daily Rosary, a simple act of charity and the careful telling of the Gospel narratives can belong naturally to ordinary domestic life. The work involved need not be expensive or elaborate. Indeed, the most memorable traditions are frequently those which children are entrusted to help make, rather than those purchased complete for their admiration.3
The distinction between the family home and the Church’s liturgy must also be maintained. Domestic customs should lead the faithful towards the Mass and the sacramental life; they are not substitutes for them. The celebration of the Nativity becomes detached from its central meaning when the religious observance is treated as an inconvenient addition to an otherwise comprehensive family programme. The child who learns that gifts are opened promptly but Mass may be fitted in only if everything else permits has received a lesson in priorities, whatever words the adults use to explain it.
Nor does any of this require parents to make Christmas gloomy, austere or artificially solemn. Joy is a proper Christian response to the Nativity, and the Church’s observance extends beyond a single exhausted morning. The Twelve Days and the feasts of Christmastide provide the opportunity for celebration after the period of preparation has fulfilled its purpose. A family can enjoy games, meals, music and gifts all the more freely when their place within a larger religious meaning has been made clear.
Commercial advertising is not responsible for all the confusions of modern family life, and an advertisement which encourages a grandmother to recover the pleasure of giving has done more than many programmes achieve. Yet the market necessarily addresses the customer as someone whose desires are to be satisfied. Parents and grandparents have an obligation which the retailer does not possess. They must help children become the kind of people who can recognise another person’s need and act for that person’s good, even when no purchase is required.
Nuntiatoria has previously argued that the domestic Church requires more than seasonal decorations and affectionate language. The Faith is transmitted through identifiable habits of prayer, worship and conduct, reinforced by the ordinary example of adults who practise what they expect the young to learn. Our December 2025 reporting also considered what it means when the public proclamation of Christ at Christmas becomes controversial.4 Our recent Domestic Church programme has accordingly emphasised preparations in which family members participate, remembrance of the Holy Souls and charity towards those who may otherwise be forgotten.3
The approach of Advent provides an opportunity to examine the Christmas being prepared in each household. A child who receives everything that has been requested may still have learned remarkably little about the feast. One who has been taught to remember the giver, to prepare something for another, to pray and to recognise the Child in the manger has been introduced to a richer inheritance. The gifts beneath the tree can then take their proper place as signs of affection, without being required to carry the entire meaning of Christmas.
FOOTNOTES
1. John Lewis Partnership, Don’t Give Up on Giving: John Lewis Unveils Its 2026 Christmas Advert, 3 November 2026.
2. John Lewis & Partners, Every John Lewis Christmas Advert Ever Aired, including The Long Wait (2011), 2026.
3. Nuntiatoria, The Domestic Church: 15–22 November 2026, 13 November 2026.
4. Nuntiatoria, Put Christ Back into Christmas: When Proclaiming Christ Becomes Extremism, 8 December 2025.





Leave a Reply