Pope Leo XIV has called upon the Catholic Church to listen to survivors of abuse, acknowledge wrongdoing and pursue justice. Yet the unresolved questions surrounding the Rupnik proceedings and the treatment of complainants in his former Diocese of Chiclayo reveal how much remains to be done. The difficulty facing Rome is no longer a shortage of declarations about safeguarding. It is whether those entrusted with ecclesiastical authority are prepared to account for what happens after the declarations have been made.
On 18 November, addressing pilgrims gathered in St Peter’s Square, Pope Leo XIV marked the Italian Episcopal Conference’s sixth National Day of Prayer for Victims and Survivors of Abuse with an appeal for the Catholic Church to listen to those who have suffered, acknowledge evil and pursue truth and justice. The theme chosen by the Italian bishops, Listening that Heals, Communities that Rebuild, provided an appropriate occasion for the Pope to renew his commitment to safeguarding. Speaking only a day after returning from South America, where he had personally met survivors of clerical and institutional abuse, Leo described the prevention and correction of abuse as part of the Christian community’s evangelical conversion. The words were entirely proper. Their significance, however, must be considered against the experience of those who have already told ecclesiastical authorities what happened to them and are still waiting to discover what those authorities intend to do about it.¹
The contrast is especially apparent in the chronology of the Pope’s recent journey. On 9 November, Leo met five survivors in Argentina; three days later, at the apostolic nunciature in Lima, he received six people who had suffered abuse involving clergy or ecclesiastical institutions. According to the Holy See, the conversations in Peru concerned listening to victims, establishing the truth and supporting their recovery. Earlier that same day, addressing the Peruvian episcopate, Leo had called for a response to abuse characterised by truth, justice, forgiveness and reparation. These encounters deserve recognition. A survivor who has spent years seeking an audience with ecclesiastical authority may reasonably attach considerable importance to being received by the Roman Pontiff himself. Yet the experience also exposes a peculiar difficulty in the Church’s present approach. The Pope can listen personally to a complainant whose case remains unresolved within institutions answerable, ultimately, to his own authority. The audience may provide consolation; whether it produces justice depends upon what follows.²
It would be unreasonable to suggest that Leo XIV has shown indifference to the suffering of abuse survivors. His public statements and personal encounters provide evidence to the contrary, and some survivors of the Sodalitium Christianae Vitae have credited Robert Prevost with helping to bring their complaints to Rome. Nevertheless, the willingness of a Pope to listen cannot settle the separate question of how effectively the ecclesiastical authorities responsible for investigating allegations have discharged their duties. A survivor may leave a papal audience encouraged by the compassion shown and remain, the following morning, no better informed about the status of an investigation. That distinction is fundamental, because the administration of justice cannot depend upon the personal accessibility of the Supreme Pontiff. It must operate through competent authorities capable of examining evidence, recognising legitimate rights and reaching determinations according to law.
Nuntiatoria has examined precisely this difficulty throughout the proceedings involving the former Jesuit Marko Ivan Rupnik. In our editorial of 31 July, Rupnik’s ‘Phantom’ Trial and the Women Left Outside It, we questioned the opacity surrounding the canonical process and the position of women who said they had sought recognition as injured parties. When five of those women addressed an open letter to Leo XIV on 23 September, the problem had acquired a more immediate character. Gloria Branciani, Mirjam Kovač, Sr Samuelle, Vida Bernard and a fifth complainant using the name Pia alleged that they had learned developments in the proceedings through the media and that repeated approaches to the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith had failed to produce adequate clarification. Their lawyer, Laura Sgrò, stated that applications for recognition as injured parties had been submitted without a determination being communicated to her clients. The women appealed for a process whose eventual judgement, whatever its outcome, could command confidence in its fairness.³
The case requires considerable canonical precision, not least because the indignation generated by allegations of abuse can encourage assumptions about rights and procedures which the law does not necessarily support. Rupnik remains entitled to a fair determination of the allegations which have not been judicially established against him. In a canonical judicial penal process, the promoter of justice conducts the prosecution, while the accused enjoys the rights of defence. Complainants do not automatically become prosecuting parties merely by reporting an alleged offence. Canon 1729 nevertheless permits a person claiming injury arising from a delict to bring a contentious action for the reparation of damages within the penal proceedings, subject to the applicable procedural requirements. Whether the particular applications submitted on behalf of Rupnik’s accusers satisfy those requirements is a question for the competent judicial authority. What requires explanation is the reported absence of a communicated determination concerning their applications.⁴
There is no obvious contradiction between preserving the confidentiality of a judicial process and informing an applicant whether a request concerning his or her own procedural status has been received and determined. The Dicastery need not disclose witness statements, publish the judges’ deliberations or allow public controversy to dictate the course of proceedings. On 22 July, Holy See Press Office Director Matteo Bruni rejected reports that the tribunal had already reached a decision, explaining that the judges were continuing to examine documentation and that information concerning their work could not be released during the proceedings. Such restrictions may be entirely justified. They do not, without further explanation, establish why directly concerned applicants should remain uncertain about the treatment of their own requests. The distinction matters to the accused as well as to complainants. The eventual credibility of a conviction or acquittal depends upon confidence that evidence has been examined according to law and that the proceedings have not been improperly influenced.⁵
The difficulty is aggravated by the history of the Rupnik affair. In October 2023, the Holy See acknowledged serious problems in the earlier handling of the allegations and a failure of outreach to those reporting abuse. Pope Francis subsequently authorised the reopening of the case notwithstanding prescription. In October 2025, the Dicastery announced the appointment of five judges selected with particular attention to their independence from the Roman Curia. Those were consequential decisions. They demonstrated that the earlier handling of the affair could not simply be defended as adequate. Yet the five women’s September letter alleged that the institution established to determine the allegations had itself failed to explain their position within the proceedings. Nuntiatoria had already identified that difficulty in July. By September, the women had placed it directly before Leo XIV, and as of this editorial’s preparation no publicly verified determination of their applications had been established. Silence in the public record does not prove that the tribunal has neglected them; it does, however, leave their reported complaint unanswered.³ ⁵
The Holy See therefore faces a question which cannot be disposed of by another expression of sympathy. If the applications have been determined, the relevant decision should be communicated to those entitled to receive it. If they remain under consideration, that position can ordinarily be explained without revealing evidence or prejudicing the eventual judgement. Should the competent authority conclude that recognition cannot lawfully be granted, the applicants should be informed according to the applicable procedure. None of these propositions requires an assumption concerning Rupnik’s guilt. They arise from the elementary expectations of an intelligible judicial process and from the Church’s own insistence that the rights of everyone concerned must be respected.
The unresolved questions surrounding the Diocese of Chiclayo illustrate another dimension of the same problem, and one which bears more directly upon Leo XIV’s earlier episcopal administration. In our September investigation, Chiclayo: The File Rome Must Now Open, we examined conflicting accounts of how allegations against two Peruvian priests had been handled during Robert Prevost’s tenure as bishop. The Diocese maintained that Prevost had conducted a preliminary investigation into allegations against Fr Eleuterio Vásquez and transmitted its acts to the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith on 21 July 2022. It subsequently reported that the Dicastery had provisionally archived the case in August 2023 for lack of evidence. The complainants disputed aspects of the diocesan account and sought access to records capable of establishing what had actually been done. These included the decree authorising the investigation, restrictions placed upon ministry and documentation concerning the transmission of evidence to Rome.⁶
Such records are important because an ecclesiastical investigation cannot be assessed simply by establishing that somebody once opened a file. The terms of the investigation, the evidence gathered, the restrictions imposed and the decisions communicated to the competent authorities all bear upon whether the process was adequate. The dispute over Vásquez’s ministry illustrates the difficulty. The diocese referred to restrictions upon his public ministry, whilst a subsequently publicised decree read by an investigator appeared to specify particular prohibitions concerning his parish duties and the hearing of confessions. Reports that Vásquez later concelebrated Mass with Prevost raise a further question about what restrictions were operative at the time. The original documents, together with any subsequent modifications, would provide a considerably firmer basis for judgement than competing recollections or institutional assurances. Their examination might vindicate particular decisions taken by Prevost, expose deficiencies in the diocesan account, or establish a more complicated sequence than either side presently describes. That is why the documents matter.⁶
More troubling still is the question of reparation. Correspondence involving Fr Giampiero Gambaro, who worked upon the renewed inquiry, records that the Diocese of Chiclayo undertook in July 2025 to issue a public apology. Gambaro proposed waiting until Vásquez had left the clerical state; the complainants asked that the apology address the diocese’s handling of their complaints and previous public statements. The correspondence also records arrangements for reimbursement of therapeutic expenses and a dispute concerning the documentation required for further assistance. These are specific undertakings and administrative decisions which can be examined independently of any eventual determination of criminal culpability. As our investigation established on 13 November, no public record of the promised apology had then been found. The diocese may possess information which has not been published, but the undertaking itself was sufficiently definite to justify asking whether it has been fulfilled.⁷
Vásquez subsequently received a dispensation from the clerical state, a development which raises an additional question about the relationship between disciplinary or administrative measures and the determination of allegations. A dispensation from the obligations of the clerical state is not equivalent to a canonical judgement establishing guilt. The Dicastery’s own Vademecum recognises circumstances in which proceedings may continue after a cleric has lost that status, including where justice to complainants warrants further examination. It also provides, in cases within its scope, that the competent ecclesiastical authority should inform alleged victims and the accused about stages of proceedings upon request, in a manner consistent with legitimate confidentiality. The question concerning Chiclayo is therefore whether an eventual judgement on the allegations was abandoned, continued or otherwise disposed of following the dispensation, and what the complainants were told. The answer should be available from the relevant acts and decisions.⁸
The two controversies must not be treated as identical. Rupnik’s accusers have sought clarification concerning participation in a judicial penal process. The women in Chiclayo have challenged the adequacy of an earlier investigation and the handling of subsequent proceedings, while seeking documentary disclosure and promised reparation. Their respective rights and the competent authorities’ obligations are governed by the particular procedures involved. Nevertheless, both cases expose the same institutional weakness: when the people who report abuse cannot establish what has happened to their complaints, the public declarations of ecclesiastical authorities cease to provide adequate reassurance. An institution may sincerely proclaim its commitment to justice while leaving essential questions about its own decisions unresolved.
That weakness cannot be corrected by pastoral vocabulary alone. The Italian bishops’ chosen theme speaks of communities rebuilding, and Chiara Griffini, president of their national safeguarding service, has emphasised the need to overcome indifference through practical responsibility. The accompanying materials encourage parishes and dioceses to consider the matter throughout the pastoral year. There is merit in such an approach, especially where a community has failed to recognise the injuries suffered by those within it. Religious abuse can damage a person’s trust in priests, religious superiors and ecclesiastical institutions, sometimes affecting the victim’s relationship with the sacramental life itself. Yet the language of healing becomes inadequate if it allows the institution to assume the role of compassionate observer whilst avoiding examination of its own conduct. Where an ecclesiastical authority has contributed to the injury through negligence, concealment or unjust treatment, that authority cannot simply offer to accompany the person who has suffered. Its conduct must also be examined.⁹
This is the wider question which Nuntiatoria addressed on 30 October in Who Investigates the Bishop? The Safeguarding Crisis That Better Communication Cannot Solve. Ecclesiastical authorities have established safeguarding offices, review boards, reporting arrangements and increasingly elaborate procedures intended to prevent abuses of power. Some have undoubtedly improved the protection available to vulnerable persons. Nevertheless, the decisive test of an investigative arrangement is what happens when the conduct of the person ultimately responsible for supervising it becomes a legitimate subject of inquiry. A bishop may be required to examine decisions taken by respected predecessors or members of his own administration. He may discover that records contradict assurances previously given, that allegations were mishandled or that safeguarding restrictions were inadequately enforced. The temptation to protect reputations is not confined to those who have committed wrongdoing. It can influence officials who fear the consequences of acknowledging mistakes within an institution to which they have devoted their lives.¹⁰
An investigation does not become independent because an episcopal conference describes it as such. Independence requires appropriate powers, access to evidence, protection against improper interference and the ability to report substantiated findings. Nor does the appointment of lay experts necessarily resolve the difficulty if their mandate, resources and freedom to disclose conclusions remain subject to the authorities whose conduct may be implicated. The Church’s canonical jurisdiction has a proper and indispensable role in determining offences against ecclesiastical discipline, the exercise of sacred ministry and the imposition of canonical penalties. Allegations involving potential criminal conduct must also be dealt with according to the requirements of civil law and the proper jurisdiction of civil authorities. The Old Roman Apostolate made this point in November 2024 when it called for prompt referral of criminal allegations and independent scrutiny of safeguarding failures. The passage of another two years has provided little reason to abandon that principle.¹⁰
Our subsequent examination of Bishop Georg Bätzing’s disagreement with Leo XIV over the description of abuse as systemic developed the argument further. Bätzing drew attention to institutional arrangements which had enabled offending priests to escape proper scrutiny, although his attempt to connect those findings with the wider programme of the German Synodal Way raised distinct doctrinal and constitutional difficulties. Safeguarding reform does not acquire a sound theological foundation merely because it is presented as a response to abuse. The Church’s divine constitution and definitive doctrine cannot be rewritten by a national assembly, but neither can ecclesiastical superiors invoke those doctrines to excuse failures in the exercise of their authority. The findings of abuse investigations require practical remedies directed towards the failures actually established. These may include independent oversight, enforceable restrictions, reliable record-keeping and scrutiny of episcopal decision-making. None requires the abandonment of Catholic ecclesiology. Indeed, the duty to protect the faithful arises directly from the purpose for which ecclesiastical authority exists.¹¹
Catholic teaching also makes the relationship between repentance and reparation more exacting than the language sometimes employed in institutional apologies. The Catechism of the Catholic Church, at paragraph 1459, teaches that sins which injure one’s neighbour give rise to an obligation to repair the harm as far as possible, even where guilt has been forgiven sacramentally. The principle is particularly relevant when ecclesiastical authorities speak of healing and reconciliation. Forgiveness does not retrospectively make an unlawful act lawful, discharge a debt of restitution or excuse a superior from investigating misconduct. Nor may a victim be required to forgive an offender as a condition of receiving assistance to which he or she is entitled. The spiritual work of reconciliation and the administration of justice possess different requirements, even where both contribute to the restoration of a person’s life.¹²
There is a corresponding danger in allowing safeguarding to become detached from its supernatural context. Bishops and priests exercise authority in the Church for the salvation of souls, and their conduct is consequently subject to obligations more serious than those arising from ordinary institutional management. An abuse of sacred authority may injure its victim precisely because the offender occupies an office associated with Christ’s ministry. When a person has been taught to recognise spiritual fatherhood in a priest or bishop, betrayal by that minister can inflict an injury which no compensation or administrative reform can fully repair. The seriousness of that damage strengthens the obligation to establish the truth. It does not diminish the rights of the accused or justify departures from proper judicial procedure. A false finding of guilt is itself an injustice, whilst an established offence left without proportionate consequences may perpetuate the original harm and expose others to danger.
There is also a question of institutional responsibility which the language of listening can inadvertently obscure. A survivor may be invited to recount a painful experience repeatedly: first to a parish priest, then to a safeguarding officer, subsequently to an investigator and perhaps eventually to a bishop or Roman official. Each encounter may be described as an exercise in attentive listening. Yet where information has already been supplied and allegations formally reported, the repetition can become another burden unless the institution is able to explain why further testimony is necessary and what will happen to it. The complainant should not be left responsible for maintaining the authorities’ attention indefinitely. Once a competent authority has received sufficient notice of an allegation, certain responsibilities belong to that authority by reason of its office.
This is particularly important when the original complaint concerns failures of government rather than the conduct of the alleged offender alone. A bishop may not have committed the offence under investigation, and the negligence of his officials cannot automatically be imputed to him. His personal responsibility must be established according to the facts, his duties and what he knew or reasonably ought to have known. Nevertheless, the faithful are entitled to expect that decisions made under episcopal authority can be examined when substantial evidence raises questions about their propriety. Sacred office does not confer administrative impeccability. Nor does criticism of a bishop’s government constitute, without more, an attack upon the Church’s indefectibility. The holiness of the Church rests upon Christ and the sanctifying means He has entrusted to her, not upon an assumption that every ecclesiastical superior governs wisely.
Leo XIV’s words on 18 November may therefore be judged according to the standard they themselves establish. If listening is intended to lead towards truth and justice, it must include a willingness to examine the conduct of ecclesiastical authorities whose decisions remain disputed. In the Rupnik proceedings, this means providing the appropriate procedural clarification to complainants who have sought recognition within the canonical process, without prejudicing the judges or the rights of the accused. In Chiclayo, it means establishing what records were sent to Rome, what restrictions were imposed, what happened to the proceedings following the dispensation granted to Vásquez and whether the diocese has fulfilled its undertaking to apologise. These are questions susceptible to documentary answers. Their resolution does not depend upon another annual observance, a further pastoral theme or a more elaborate description of the Church’s concern.
The Pope possesses the authority to require an independent examination of the administrative decisions taken in his former diocese and of the records held by the competent Roman offices, with appropriate protection for complainants and for those accused. Such a review need not presume misconduct by Leo himself. Indeed, a properly constituted inquiry might establish that some allegations concerning his earlier administration are unjustified. That possibility supplies another reason for examining the evidence rather than allowing suspicion and competing public statements to stand in place of findings. Where the Holy See’s own records can establish what happened, leaving the matter unresolved serves neither the complainants nor the reputation of the offices concerned.
The Italian bishops’ initiative contains an entirely sound Christian principle. Communities damaged by abuse require the truth to be acknowledged and wrongs to be repaired as far as justice permits. But those who have survived abuse should not be obliged to measure the Church’s sincerity by the warmth of her language or the frequency of her commemorations. They are entitled to expect that allegations will be investigated competently, that lawful requests will receive appropriate answers and that the officials responsible for defective decisions will not be shielded from scrutiny by the dignity of their offices.
Leo XIV has asked the Catholic Church to listen in a manner that heals. The more searching question is whether the Church’s authorities are prepared to hear what the evidence may disclose about their own conduct, particularly where the findings might be embarrassing or costly. In Rome, the women who accuse Rupnik are still seeking clarity about their place within the proceedings. In Chiclayo, complainants have asked for the documents and reparation which would allow the handling of their allegations to be properly examined. Until those questions receive satisfactory answers, the language of rebuilding will remain accompanied by an uncomfortable fact: those who have already spoken are still waiting for the institutions which heard them to account for what they did.
FOOTNOTES
¹ Holy See Press Office, General Audience, 18 November 2026; Italian Episcopal Conference, Ascolto che cura, comunità che ricostruisce, 17 September 2026.
² Vatican News, Pope Leo XIV meets with abuse victims in Argentina, 9 November 2026; Pope Leo XIV meets with abuse victims in Peru, 13 November 2026; Leo XIV, Meeting with the Bishops of Peru, 12 November 2026.
³ Nuntiatoria, Rupnik’s Accusers Appeal to Leo XIV: The Women Are Still Outside the Door, 25 September 2026, including its references to the July investigation and the complainants’ open letter.
⁴ Holy See, Code of Canon Law, Canons 1721–1731.
⁵ Vatican News, Matteo Bruni: Reports regarding Rupnik entirely unfounded, assessment still underway, 22 July 2026; Nuntiatoria, Rupnik’s Accusers Appeal to Leo XIV, 25 September 2026.
⁶ Nuntiatoria, Chiclayo: The File Rome Must Now Open, 18 September 2026; Diocese of Chiclayo, Statement concerning the Prevost case, 10 September 2024.
⁷ Giampiero Gambaro and the Chiclayo complainants, Correspondencia con la Diócesis de Chiclayo, July–October 2025, particularly correspondence of 1, 4, 15 and 22 July.
⁸ Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, Vademecum on Certain Points of Procedure in Treating Cases of Sexual Abuse of Minors Committed by Clerics, Version 2.0, 5 June 2022, nos. 157, 160–164.
⁹ Italian Episcopal Conference, Ascolto che cura, comunità che ricostruisce: VI Giornata nazionale di preghiera, 17 September 2026.
¹⁰ Nuntiatoria, Who Investigates the Bishop? The Safeguarding Crisis That Better Communication Cannot Solve, 30 October 2026; Archbishop Jerome Lloyd, Safeguarding First – Always, 15 November 2024.
¹¹ Nuntiatoria, The Bishop Who Rebuked Rome: Bätzing, Systemic Abuse and the German Synodal Agenda, 6 November 2026.
¹² Catechism of the Catholic Church, The Acts of the Penitent, §§1459–1460.






Leave a Reply