The Law of Truth and the Peace of Christ
MASS Lex veritátis
LESSON 2 Timothy 3: 14-17; 4, 1-5
GOSPEL St Matthew 10: 28-33
HOMILIST Mt Revd Jerome Lloyd OSJV
In the Name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost. Amen.
“The law of truth was in his mouth, and iniquity was not found in his lips: he walked with Me in peace and in equity, and turned many away from iniquity.”
With these words from the Prophet Malachias, Holy Mother Church gives us the character and mission of Saint Irenaeus. Truth was in his mouth; peace marked his footsteps; conversion followed his teaching. He did not obtain peace by concealing the truth. He established peace by defending it. He did not preserve unity by treating error as unimportant. He restored unity by leading souls back to the Faith handed down from the Apostles.
Saint Irenaeus was born in Asia Minor, probably between A.D. 130 and 140. As a young man he heard Saint Polycarp, Bishop of Smyrna, who suffered martyrdom around A.D. 155. Polycarp had himself known Saint John the Apostle.
We therefore have an extraordinary chain of living memory: Saint John, who rested upon the breast of Our Lord at the Last Supper; Saint Polycarp, who listened to Saint John; and Saint Irenaeus, who listened to Polycarp. When Irenaeus spoke of Apostolic Tradition, he was not appealing to an abstraction. He remembered the voice of a man who had heard an Apostle preach.
Irenaeus later travelled westward to Gaul and became a priest of the Church of Lyons. In A.D. 177, during the persecution under the Emperor Marcus Aurelius, the Christians of Lyons and Vienne endured imprisonment, torture and death. Their aged bishop, Saint Pothinus, then more than ninety years old, was beaten and cast into prison, where he died from his injuries.
During that persecution, the imprisoned clergy sent Irenaeus to Rome with a letter for Pope Eleutherius. When he returned, he succeeded the martyred Pothinus as Bishop of Lyons, probably in A.D. 178. He became a bishop in a Church still wet with the blood of her martyrs. Today’s Gospel was therefore no pious figure of speech for him: “Fear ye not them that kill the body, and are not able to kill the soul.”
The Church was threatened not only by persecutors from without, but also by false teachers. The Gnostics claimed secret knowledge available only to a spiritual elite. They used the names of Christ, the Apostles and the Scriptures, but placed beneath those names a different religion. They distorted the Incarnation, despised the material creation, and promised salvation through hidden teaching.
Against them, Irenaeus wrote his great work Against Heresies during the closing decades of the second century. Error, he knew, rarely announces itself as falsehood. It promises enlightenment, progress, freedom, compassion or a more mature understanding. It suggests that the Apostolic Faith is too simple, too old or too restrictive for enlightened minds.
Saint Irenaeus answered by pointing to the public Faith of the Church. Christ taught His Apostles. The Apostles preached openly and entrusted their doctrine to the Churches they founded. Those Churches possessed bishops succeeding one another in visible order. The truth was not hidden in private revelations or secret circles. It was confessed throughout the Catholic world in the rule of faith, the Scriptures, the Sacraments and the succession of bishops.
He appealed particularly to the Roman Church, founded by the glorious Apostles Peter and Paul. On the Vigil of their feast, this testimony carries special force. The Faith defended by Irenaeus was the Faith preached at Rome by Peter, sealed there by the blood of Paul, and handed down through the succession of lawful pastors.
The Epistle therefore commands Saint Timothy: “Continue thou in those things which thou hast learned and which have been committed to thee.” The word is continue. Saint Paul does not tell Timothy to construct a new Christianity for a new age. The Faith is not ours to redesign. It is a sacred deposit: received, guarded, lived and handed on.
This command speaks with particular force to Catholics who, in our own time, labour to preserve the traditional Faith, the ancient Roman liturgy and the doctrine received from the saints. Traditional Catholics are often accused of living in the past merely because they refuse to treat the past as though it were dead. Yet Catholic Tradition is not nostalgia. It is the living transmission of what the Church has received from Christ.
To cherish the Mass of our forefathers, to insist upon the Real Presence, the sacrificial nature of the priesthood, the necessity of conversion, the gravity of sin, the permanence of doctrine and the Kingship of Christ is not to invent a faction within the Church. It is to ask that Catholics remain recognisably Catholic.
The struggle of traditionalists is therefore not fundamentally a struggle over taste, language, lace, music or ceremonial. These things have their place, but beneath them lies a deeper question: may one generation treat as harmful what countless saints received as holy? May doctrine formerly taught with certainty be obscured because it has become unwelcome? May reverence be dismissed as rigidity, continuity as disobedience, and fidelity as division?
Saint Irenaeus teaches us how to answer. We do not begin with novelty, fashion or administrative power. We begin with what has been handed down. We ask what the Church believed, prayed and taught through the centuries. Genuine development unfolds what was already present; it does not contradict what came before. A tree may grow, but it cannot grow by cutting itself off from its roots.
This does not mean that every traditionalist opinion is infallible, nor that anger becomes virtuous merely because it is directed against modernism. Fidelity to Tradition requires humility as well as courage. We must never allow devotion to the old liturgy to become contempt for souls, nor rightful resistance to error to become a licence for bitterness, rash judgement or pride.
Saint Paul commands: “Preach the word: be instant in season, out of season; reprove, entreat, rebuke in all patience and doctrine.” The last words matter: “in all patience and doctrine.” Truth must be defended, but it must be defended as truth, not as an instrument of wounded vanity. The traditional Catholic must resist error without becoming spiritually deformed by the struggle against it.
Saint Paul warns that a time will come when men “will not endure sound doctrine,” but will seek teachers according to their own desires. This occurs whenever men first decide how they wish to live and then search for a religion which will bless their decision. It occurs whenever hard truths are silenced, moral commandments softened, or revealed doctrine recast in language so ambiguous that error may dwell beside truth without being disturbed.
A shepherd who offers such reassurance may appear gentle, but he is not charitable. A physician who conceals a mortal disease is not merciful. A watchman who sees danger and remains silent is not peaceful. True charity desires not merely that men should feel affirmed, but that they should be converted and saved.
Yet the Church presents Saint Irenaeus not only as a defender of truth, but as an instrument of peace. His name means “peaceful,” and the Proper of his Mass repeatedly joins truth with peace. The Collect praises him because, through his strenuous teaching of truth, he confuted heresies and established peace in the Church.
Around A.D. 190 or 191, this character appeared during the controversy concerning the date of Easter. Pope Saint Victor considered breaking communion with the Churches of Asia Minor, which preserved a different Paschal custom. Irenaeus intervened respectfully, urging that an ancient disciplinary difference should not divide Catholics who professed the same Faith.
Here is true Catholic discernment. Irenaeus was severe against heresy because heresy corrupts revealed truth. He was conciliatory concerning legitimate custom because charity forbids unnecessary division. He did not confuse doctrine with discipline, nor peace with compromise. He knew when firmness was required and when patience better served the Church.
This too is relevant today. Catholics must distinguish the immutable deposit of faith from prudential decisions, temporary policies and disciplinary measures. Authority deserves reverence, but authority is given to guard the Faith, not to obscure it; to protect Tradition, not to make it suspect; to build up the Church, not to estrange the faithful from their spiritual inheritance.
Traditional Catholics must therefore resist two temptations. The first is servility: the notion that every novelty must be welcomed merely because it is imposed. The second is rebellion: the notion that every act of authority may be dismissed merely because it is painful. Saint Irenaeus offers a more Catholic path—firmness in doctrine, reverence towards office, patience in suffering, and fidelity without servility.
The proper Last Gospel from this Fifth Sunday after Pentecost turns the same lesson towards our consciences. Our Lord commands us to be reconciled with our brother before offering our gift at the altar. It is not enough to condemn public error while secretly nourishing anger. It is possible to defend true doctrine while speaking cruelly. It is possible to love Tradition as an idea while violating charity in one’s home, parish or community.
Christ traces murder back to its root in the heart. Contempt, vindictiveness and cherished resentment contradict the peace of God. We may not use zeal for truth as a disguise for pride. Nor may we use charity as an excuse for cowardice. Saint Irenaeus shows us the Catholic union of both virtues: truth without compromise and charity without sentimentality.
Reconciliation does not mean pretending that evil is good. Forgiveness does not abolish justice. Peace does not require the denial of truth. It requires us to oppose falsehood without hatred, correct our neighbour without contempt, and remember that we ourselves live only by the mercy of God.
Today we remain also within the Octave of Saint John the Baptist. John pointed away from himself and towards Christ: “Behold the Lamb of God.” Tomorrow Saints Peter and Paul stand before us as the pillars of the Roman Church. John, Peter, Paul and Irenaeus belong to one continuous testimony. Each received the truth; each confessed it; each handed it on; each was willing to suffer rather than betray it.
That testimony reaches its sacramental summit upon the altar. Saint Irenaeus appealed to the Holy Eucharist against the Gnostics. They despised the body and material creation; but the Catholic Faith proclaims that the Word was made flesh. The Son of God took a true body from the Blessed Virgin, offered that Body upon the Cross, raised it from the tomb, and now gives that same Body to us beneath the appearances of bread.
The ancient Roman Mass expresses this faith with an incomparable clarity. Its silence, gestures, orientation, offertory and sacrificial language direct the soul away from man and towards God. It teaches not merely by words but by reverence. It forms Catholics to understand that the altar is Calvary made present, that the priest acts in the person of Christ, and that Holy Communion is not ordinary food but the Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of the Lord.
To preserve such a treasure is not antiquarianism. It is an act of charity towards generations yet unborn. Saint Irenaeus preserved the Faith he had received from Polycarp; we too are obliged to hand on what we ourselves inherited. Tradition is not the worship of ashes. It is the guardianship of a sacred fire.
Saint Irenaeus died around the beginning of the third century, traditionally about A.D. 202, and the Latin Church honours him as bishop and martyr. The exact circumstances of his death remain uncertain, but his witness is unmistakable. He stood within two generations of Saint John. He defended the Scriptures, the episcopal succession, the Roman primacy, the unity of the Faith and the reality of the Eucharist.
The Communion antiphon places these words upon his lips: “See ye, that I have not laboured for myself only, but for all that seek out the truth.” He laboured for us. Across more than eighteen centuries, his voice still tells us where truth is found: not in novelty, secrecy or private invention, but in the Faith received from Christ, preached by the Apostles, preserved by the Church and made present upon her altars.
May Saint Irenaeus obtain for traditional Catholics neither cowardice nor bitterness, neither compromise nor rebellion, but supernatural constancy. May we preserve without pride, resist without hatred, suffer without despair, and hand on without alteration what we have received.
May the law of truth be in our mouths and the peace of Christ in our hearts. Then, reconciled with our brethren and steadfast in Apostolic Tradition, we may approach the altar to receive Him Who is Truth Incarnate, the Prince of Peace and the Life of the world.
In the Name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost. Amen.
Homilies Archive
Mass Propers
DAILY MASS ONLINE
One of the earliest online apostolates dedicated to the Traditional Latin Mass, Old Roman TV began broadcasting the Holy Sacrifice on the Feast of the Assumption, 15 August 2008. During the COVID-19 pandemic, additional programming — devotions, catechesis, and conferences — was added to support the faithful in prayer and formation.
Support the daily Holy Mass on Old Roman TV by offering a Mass intention — for loved ones, thanksgiving, or the repose of souls. Your intention helps sustain the sacred liturgy and brings grace to those you remember before God’s altar.
SUPPORT THE DAILY MASS ONLINE
Likely the world’s longest-running daily online broadcast of the
Traditional Latin Mass, streaming faithfully since the
Feast of the Assumption 2008.
This apostolate cannot continue without immediate help
Please support us with a contribution toward
chapel rent, sacristy supplies, operating costs, and web-hosting.
Our essential monthly costs reach £1,000.
Leave a Reply