Ten years after the first Red Wednesday, Aid to the Church in Need’s latest evidence reveals contrasting patterns of violence, legal repression and criminal prosecution across countries where Christians face persecution. The arrests, restrictive laws and unresolved attacks deserve closer scrutiny than anniversary gestures alone.

India recorded 814 incidents of anti-Christian violence in 2024. In 2025, the figure fell to more than 700. Yet Aid to the Church in Need (ACN), publishing its latest assessment of Christian persecution, concludes that conditions in India have continued to deteriorate. Meanwhile, in Iran, 254 Christians were reportedly arrested in 2025, approximately twice the number recorded the previous year. Two countries, two rather different developments, both revealing how easily the condition of persecuted Christians can be misunderstood when individual statistics are detached from the laws and institutions governing their lives.¹

These findings deserve particular attention as ACN marks the tenth anniversary of its Red Wednesday campaign on 18 November. In Ireland, the charity’s president, Father Timothy Bartlett, has warned that the active persecution of Christians remains a crime which the world prefers not to see. His remarks, reported by the Catholic Herald, come as churches, cathedrals and public buildings across several countries are illuminated red in solidarity with Christians suffering because of their faith.³

The anniversary provides an appropriate occasion for remembering those who have been murdered, imprisoned or dispossessed. Its real value, however, depends upon what governments, diplomatic institutions and Christian communities are prepared to recognise in the evidence which ACN has assembled. The reports published over the past two years permit a more exacting examination than the customary references to millions of persecuted Christians.

ACN’s Persecuted and Forgotten? 2024–2026, released on 27 October, examines eighteen countries between 1 August 2024 and 30 June 2026. It finds that oppression of Christians worsened in 55 per cent of those countries. None recorded an overall improvement. The previous report, covering 2022–2024, identified deterioration in more than 60 per cent of the eighteen countries then examined, with Vietnam alone showing slight improvement.¹ ²

The comparison requires some care. These are qualitative assessments of selected countries, and the selection is not identical: Mali appears in the latest report, while Saudi Arabia featured in its predecessor. A country classified as unchanged may remain a place in which Christians experience intolerable conditions. North Korea is an obvious example. Nor does a slightly lower proportion of deteriorating countries amount to evidence of a recovery in religious freedom.

Indeed, the more useful comparison concerns the particular forms of persecution recorded.

In India, the relationship between legislation and organised hostility is especially revealing. The reduction in recorded violent incidents from 814 to more than 700 deserves acknowledgement. ACN nevertheless documents the expansion of state laws restricting religious conversion, attacks upon Christian worship and instances in which families have been prevented from burying their dead according to their faith. By the end of the reporting period, fourteen Indian states had introduced legislation of the kind commonly described as anti-conversion laws.¹

Such legislation is ostensibly intended to prevent coercion and fraudulent religious conversion. That objective cannot excuse its misuse against legitimate religious activity. ACN records accusations of unlawful conversion being directed against Catholic priests, religious sisters and catechists, including an assault upon a Catholic mission party in Odisha in August 2025. Its evidence also includes the expulsion of twenty-six Christian families from a village in Chhattisgarh in June 2026 after they refused to renounce their religion.

The distinction is important because there can be fewer reported assaults in one calendar year while the legal and social conditions under which Christians live become more oppressive. Conversely, the existence of restrictive legislation does not establish that every prosecution under it is unjust. It is the conduct being criminalised, the evidence presented, the treatment of defendants and the courts’ application of the law which must be examined.

Iran presents a more directly measurable deterioration in the use of state coercion. ACN reports 254 arrests of Christians in 2025, approximately double the number recorded in 2024. Converts from Islam and members of evangelical communities remain particularly vulnerable. Activities associated with conversion and evangelisation are frequently prosecuted under national-security provisions, allowing the authorities to treat religious practice as evidence of hostility towards the state.¹

The cases are specific. In November 2024, Christian convert Toumaj Ariankia received a ten-year prison sentence following convictions involving evangelisation and alleged collaboration with hostile foreign powers. ACN also records the case of Catholic convert Ghazal Marzban, who was rearrested in May 2026 and sentenced to nine years and eight months’ imprisonment on charges including collusion against national security.

Here persecution has entered the ordinary machinery of criminal justice. The individual is arrested, charged, convicted and punished under provisions whose political purpose is scarcely concealed by their legal terminology. The Catholic convert is presented as a threat to national security because the state regards the independence of religious conscience as a potential challenge to its authority.

Pakistan illustrates a related problem in which criminal legislation, popular religious hostility and unequal access to justice reinforce one another. The Center for Social Justice recorded 344 blasphemy cases in 2024, approximately six per cent involving Christians. ACN also documents the September 2024 death sentence imposed upon Christian mother Shagufta Kiran following allegations concerning material shared on WhatsApp. These are actual judicial proceedings, distinguishable from the wider number of accusations and incidents of intimidation.¹

The circumstances surrounding forced conversions and marriages of minority girls are particularly troubling. Pakistan has introduced protective reforms, including legislation raising the minimum marriage age within Islamabad Capital Territory to eighteen. Nevertheless, the effectiveness of such protections remains disputed where courts accept claims of conversion or apply interpretations of religious law which undermine statutory safeguards.

The failure to punish perpetrators of anti-Christian violence requires equal attention. Following the attacks upon the Christian community of Jaranwala in August 2023, in which churches and homes were destroyed or damaged, Christians continued protesting the absence of effective justice. ACN cites reports that, as of August 2025, none of the 5,213 people accused in connection with those attacks had been convicted. That figure concerns the reported state of proceedings at the time; it should not be mistaken for a finding that every accused person was individually proved guilty.

Yet the disparity raises a serious question. When accusations against Christians result in capital sentences, while large-scale attacks upon Christian property produce prolonged failures of prosecution, it is necessary to investigate the operation of the justice system itself. Religious freedom cannot be secured by legislation which is selectively enforced.

The persecution of the Catholic Church in Nicaragua has a different political origin. The government of Daniel Ortega and Rosario Murillo has treated ecclesiastical independence and criticism of state conduct as threats to its authority. Priests and bishops have been arrested or expelled, Church institutions confiscated and public religious observances restricted. ACN records at least 261 Church personnel expelled from the country, including nearly 140 priests and more than ninety religious sisters. These are cumulative figures, rather than expulsions occurring exclusively during the latest reporting period.¹

In March 2026, the authorities reportedly prohibited priestly and diaconal ordinations in four dioceses whose bishops remained in exile. The practical consequence reaches beyond the immediate suffering of individual clerics. A government which interferes with the formation and ordination of priests attempts to determine whether a religious community can perpetuate its sacramental and institutional life.

A further set of ACN figures makes the situation more complicated, and more revealing. Its separate investigation into attacks upon clergy found that twenty-eight priests and religious worldwide were arrested or otherwise deprived of freedom for reasons associated with persecution during 2025, compared with seventy-two in 2024. Much of the reduction was attributable to Nicaragua, where the figure fell from forty-four to two.⁵

A reduction in arrests is welcome where it reflects the restoration of liberty. But the disappearance of detention figures cannot be treated as proof of improvement when governments have already expelled substantial numbers of clergy or otherwise prevented them from exercising their ministry. An exile does not cease to be persecuted simply because he is no longer occupying a prison cell.

The same investigation recorded nineteen priests, seminarians and religious sisters murdered worldwide in 2025, compared with thirteen in 2024. Kidnappings fell overall, from forty-four to thirty-eight, although Nigeria registered twenty-one new abductions during 2025 against fourteen the previous year. These figures encompass different circumstances, including religious persecution, conflict and other forms of violent criminality. They cannot all be attributed automatically to a single religious motive.⁵

Nigeria’s continuing crisis has featured repeatedly in Nuntiatoria. Our November 2025 reporting examined the abduction of pupils and staff at St Mary’s Catholic Schools in Papiri, Niger State, within the wider pattern of violence afflicting Christian communities in the north and Middle Belt. Subsequent ACN reporting records the release announced by the authorities in December 2025, but the wider insecurity remains.⁷

ACN estimates that at least one million Christians are among more than 3.5 million internally displaced people in Nigeria. The distinction matters: the entire displaced population must not be presented as Christian, and the country’s conflicts have claimed Muslim victims as well. Nevertheless, testimony from Christian communities identifies attacks in which religious identity, demands for conversion and the deliberate targeting of Christian settlements have played a demonstrable part.¹

This is consistent with the argument advanced in our previous examination of the problem. Ethnic rivalry, disputes over land, criminal organisation and failures of government protection are real features of the Nigerian crisis. They provide essential context for understanding particular incidents. They do not account adequately for the conduct of militants who attack churches, threaten Christian clergy or demand conversion under pain of violence.

The condition of Christians in Mozambique raises comparable questions. In May, Nuntiatoria examined the destruction of St Louis de Montfort Parish in Cabo Delgado, where the church, priests’ residence and associated buildings were attacked by jihadist militants. The new ACN report places that incident within a conflict in which, according to sources it cites, approximately one thousand Christians have been killed since 2017.⁸

Burkina Faso remains subject to extensive Islamist territorial control. Sudan’s Christians face particular dangers amid a civil war which has devastated the civilian population and religious infrastructure. Syria, meanwhile, has moved from an assessment of no overall change in the previous ACN edition to deterioration in the latest, following the overthrow of Bashar al-Assad and renewed attacks upon minority communities.¹ ²

These examples expose the limitations of speaking about Christian persecution as though it were a single phenomenon. In Iran, the convert may be sentenced by a court for evangelising. In Nicaragua, the bishop may be expelled and the seminary confiscated. In parts of Africa, a Christian village may be attacked by armed militants operating where public authority has substantially collapsed. The responsibilities of the state differ in each case, although the obligation to protect innocent persons and uphold the law remains.

Our October 2025 examination of ACN’s Religious Freedom in the World report addressed the wider finding that approximately 5.4 billion people lived in countries where religious freedom was seriously restricted or inadequately protected. That figure concerns people of every religion and none. It must not be confused with ACN’s estimates of 413 million Christians living in countries with serious religious-freedom violations, or approximately 220 million directly exposed to persecution.⁹ ⁴

Different definitions and datasets produce different totals. More importantly, living in a country where religious liberty is restricted does not prove that every inhabitant experiences persecution personally. The seriousness of the subject makes accuracy an obligation rather than an inconvenience.

In June, Nuntiatoria considered the newly established shrine to persecuted Christians in Oslo and the findings of the British Government’s Truro Review. That investigation identified a persistent reluctance in Western institutions to recognise the religious character of violence against Christians. It also insisted upon the equal protection owed to every person suffering religious persecution.⁶

ACN’s latest findings reinforce that argument while providing grounds for a more exacting assessment of the countries concerned. Persecution can be obscured through careless generalisation as readily as through diplomatic silence. It is necessary to name the religious motives of persecutors when the evidence establishes them, while distinguishing those motives from wider conflicts whose victims belong to several communities.

There is also a practical question concerning accountability. How many of the attacks documented by ACN have led to convictions? How many prisoners have been released because the relevant prosecution was unlawful? How many displaced Christian families have been able to return safely to their homes? Where legislation is used to prevent conversion, evangelisation or Catholic sacramental life, what effective representations have been made by governments which profess to support freedom of religion?

These questions can be answered only through continued country-level investigation, with documented cases and measurable outcomes.

Red Wednesday has succeeded in establishing a recognisable public expression of solidarity with persecuted Christians. After ten years, its continuing necessity is evident from the cases ACN has recorded. The illumination of churches and public buildings may awaken consciences which would otherwise remain indifferent. Whether that attention can be translated into protection depends upon the less photogenic business of legal reform, diplomatic pressure, credible investigations and the prosecution of offenders.

For the Christian families of Jaranwala, the converts imprisoned in Iran, the priests expelled from Nicaragua and the communities displaced from Nigeria’s Middle Belt, those are the developments by which progress will ultimately have to be judged.


¹ Aid to the Church in Need, Persecuted and Forgotten? A Report on Christians Oppressed for Their Faith 2024–2026, October 2026.
² Aid to the Church in Need, Persecuted and Forgotten? 2022–2024, October 2024.
³ Corrie Douglas-Young, Christian persecution remains a ‘crime the world prefers not to see’, ACN Ireland warns, Catholic Herald, 18 November 2026.
⁴ Aid to the Church in Need, Religious Freedom in the World Report 2025, October 2025.
⁵ Aid to the Church in Need International, Significant Drop in Arrests of Priests in 2025 but Deaths Increase, 30 January 2026.
⁶ Nuntiatoria, A Shrine Against Forgetfulness: Oslo, the Martyrs, and the Selective Conscience of the West, 26 June 2026.
⁷ Nuntiatoria, Night Falls on Papiri: The Continuing Persecution of Catholics in Northern Nigeria, 21 November 2025.
⁸ Nuntiatoria, Mozambique’s Burned Churches and Africa’s Forgotten Christian War, 8 May 2026.
⁹ Nuntiatoria, 5.4 Billion People at Risk of Losing Freedom of Religion: A Global Crisis of Faith and Conscience, 24 October 2025.

Never miss an edition of Nuntiatoria

Serious Catholic journalism, theological analysis, liturgical commentary and the weekly Ordo, delivered directly to your inbox.

Subscribe free. If you value this independent work, you can also become a Nuntiatoria Supporter and help keep our journalism and pastoral resources freely available to everyone.

Free to read. Sustained by readers.

Leave a Reply

Trending

Live Q&A with Archbishop Jerome Lloyd: questions on faith, tradition and the spiritual life

LIVE TODAY · THURSDAY · 5PM GMT

Join ✠ Jerome Lloyd for questions on faith, tradition and the spiritual life.

WATCH LIVE ON OLD ROMAN TV

Request a Mass — for the living and the departed

NOVEMBER • MONTH OF THE HOLY SOULS

Remember your loved ones at the altar

Have a traditional Requiem Mass offered for the repose of your departed family, friends and benefactors—whether they died recently or many years ago.

Your Mass stipend also helps support the priest’s ministry and the work of the Old Roman Apostolate.

Request a Mass

Suggested stipend: £15 per Mass.

SUPPORT NUNTIATORIA

Become a supporting subscriber

Help sustain an independent traditional Catholic voice. Your paid subscription supports the writing and publication of Nuntiatoria and the Old Roman Apostolate.

If you value this ministry, please help keep it growing through regular support.

Become a supporting subscriber

Or subscribe free

Already a paid subscriber? Thank you for your support. If you currently subscribe free, please consider becoming a paid supporter.

NUNTIATORIA

Help keep Nuntiatoria freely available

If you value Nuntiatoria, please consider making a donation. Your gift helps meet the costs of producing and publishing its articles, maintaining this website and sustaining the ministry behind it.

Every contribution, however modest, is gratefully received. Thank you for your generosity and your prayers.

Donate via PayPal

You will be taken to PayPal to make your donation.