A Library of Catholic Formation | The Young Man’s Guide (1910) | Part First: The Panoply of War | The Shield of Faith | Chapter III, pp. 11–13.
EDITORIAL NOTE. The text below is reproduced from the 1910 edition. The peasant’s conversation with the priest is presented as a moral illustration, not a documented historical incident. The author’s remarks about animal intelligence and his piano analogy reflect the philosophical and scientific assumptions of his period. The contemporary reflection distinguishes the Catholic doctrine of the spiritual soul from the more limited arguments offered here for its existence.
III. The Music of the Soul
1. A PEASANT betook himself to a priest in Rome, and laid before him the following extraordinary doubt. “Your Reverence,” he said, “I can scarcely believe that I have a soul!” It may readily be imagined that this unexpected statement caused the priest no slight astonishment. It cost him an effort to discover how he could, in a brief and clear manner, convince the foolish man that he really had a soul. The Spirit of God taught him what to say.
He questioned the doubter thus: “Now, my good man, why can not you believe that you have a soul?” “Because I can not see it!” “Well, then, think of whatever you like”; and after the lapse of a few minutes he inquired: “Have you really thought of something?” “Yes, I have done as your Reverence bade me.” “But,” continued the priest, “I can not believe that you have thought of anything.” “And why not, may I ask?” “Because I can not see your thought.” In this convincing manner was the man freed from his doubt.
For, indeed, it would be unreasonable to doubt that we are able to think, will, and remember. On this account it would be equally unreasonable to refuse to believe in the presence within us of a soul endowed with reason.
2. Thus the power of thought is a proof of the existence within us of an independent and rational soul. But stop! We have reckoned without our host, that is, without the modern unbelieving scientists! They think scornfully of our old-fashioned ideas, and exclaim: “O you silly people! Thought is nothing more than an act of the brain! In order to do this there is no need of a soul; that is to say, no need of a spiritual and independent being.”
But pause awhile, you wiseacres, and allow us to ask you a question. From a neighboring house the sound of a masterly performance on the piano reaches our ears.
Do you mean to assert that the music is nothing more than an act of the piano, that the instrument plays of itself? Every child would say of you, “these people are too clever by half.” Therefore, good gentlemen, we continue to believe that thought is the music of the soul; and that where thoughts exist, there must be a soul capable of thought, just as, where there is the sound of music from a piano, there must be also a performer.
3. What now is the case of animals, especially those which are most highly trained, as for instance the dog, the horse, or the monkey? Have not they likewise a soul? Certainly the animal possesses sensible impressions, feelings, impulses, a memory, and as far as this goes, one may speak of a soul. But the soul of the animal is essentially and immeasurably removed from the soul of man, because it is not possessed of reason.
Even, to use a common phrase, the most intelligent animal is destitute of self-consciousness and reason or understanding. Every child knows that “two and two make four,” but no animal could comprehend the fact, though it were to try to do so for a century or more.
4. Upon us, however, there shines not merely the light of natural reason, but also the sun of faith. The rays of this sun enable us to see that our soul is like unto God, an image of God. Holy Scripture expressly teaches us this, for in the beginning of it we read that God solemnly pronounced these words of vast import: “Let us make man to our image and likeness.”
Thus if man is like God, who is a pure spirit, this likeness can certainly not consist in anything physical or material, but in the possession of a soul, which is a spirit also, made in God’s image, simple as God is, living as God is, immortal as God is. Wherefore, lay well to heart the following verse:
O man, to God’s own image made,
Destined that God to see in light arrayed,
Keep thou His law, unto thy ways take heed;
Let love of Him rule every word and deed.
CONTEMPORARY REFLECTION AND APPLICATION
The young man who first read this chapter in 1910 was being invited to defend the existence of his soul against a materialism which regarded human thought as nothing beyond the operation of the brain. The question has become more intricate in our own day. Neurology can describe relationships between particular cerebral processes and particular human abilities, while computers can produce fluent prose, solve problems and imitate some features of reasoning. These developments make careful distinctions more necessary than the author’s spirited exchange with his imagined scientific opponents might suggest.
The Catholic doctrine is that man is a unity of body and rational soul. His body is neither a disposable vessel nor an unfortunate hindrance to the spiritual life. St Thomas Aquinas describes the rational soul as the form of the body; it is the principle by which this particular living body is a human being. The Church teaches both that the soul is spiritual and immortal and that it will be reunited with the body in the resurrection. A Christian therefore has reason to respect his bodily life and the bodily lives of others, including those diminished by illness or disability.2
The piano comparison is memorable, although it cannot settle every objection which present-day philosophy of mind or neuroscience might raise. Injury to the brain can alter memory, speech, judgement and personality. Catholic philosophy need not deny these observations. In ordinary human life, intellectual activity makes use of sensation and imagination, and these depend upon bodily organs. A demonstration that thought is ordinarily exercised through a functioning brain does not, of itself, establish that human understanding is exhaustively explicable as a physical event. Equally, the incompleteness of a scientific explanation should never be offered as though it constituted a proof of the soul.
The author’s treatment of animals also calls for proportion. Research into animal learning, memory and behaviour has supplied evidence which his confident generalisations do not acknowledge. The scholastic distinction concerns the rational human capacity to grasp universal truths and deliberate about moral ends; it should not become an excuse for denying animals their remarkable natural capacities or for treating creatures entrusted to human care cruelly.
For a young man, however, the immediate consequence of this chapter is more intimate than a dispute about scientific method. He possesses faculties of understanding and will for which he is responsible. No employer, social circle, political faction or algorithm can make the moral choice for him. He may be persuaded, pressured or distracted; he remains obliged to seek what is true and to choose what is good. To form his judgement he needs more than the ability to repeat an argument he has heard online.
The increasing ease with which an artificial system can supply an answer makes this responsibility more evident. A machine may propose a line of reasoning, but the man using it must consider its truth, the justice of the action proposed and its consequences for those affected. The Christian understanding of personal dignity does not depend upon a comparison of computational speed or verbal fluency. Nor does a man whose memory or speech is impaired cease to bear the image of God.
This gives parents and educators a positive task. Boys should learn to reason patiently, ask what a claim actually establishes, acknowledge when they do not know, and resist the temptation to win an argument by mockery. They should also learn that the practice of religion addresses the whole person. Prayer and sacramental life, honest work, restraint in entertainment, care of the body, friendship and service to those in need are not separate compartments which happen to belong to a Catholic household.
Fr Lasance ends by taking the reader back to Genesis. The image of God establishes a dignity prior to achievement, wealth or public approval. A young man who remembers that his intellect is ordered to truth and his will to the good possesses a better measure of manhood than the approval of strangers or the inventions of an advertising industry. He will also have reason to regard every other human being, including those least able to defend themselves, as a neighbour rather than an instrument.
FOOTNOTES
1. F. X. Lasance (ed.), The Young Man’s Guide (New York: Benziger Brothers, 1910), Part First, Chapter III, pp. 11–13.
2. Catechism of the Catholic Church, §§ 362–366; St Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, I, q. 75.
Next: Chapter IV, “Death Is Not Annihilation.”





Leave a Reply